Wednesday, December 14, 2011

There Is No Simple Right In Right Livelihood


The Serenity of the landscape is deceptive
Its reality is a complex web connecting 
Chemically driven agriculture
To a commodities market
In a greed driven world 
When we try to sort out what we Buddhists should do about our work, we usually focus our attention on the Buddha’s Eightfold Noble Path. It seems sensible to start there since Right Livelihood is one of the three Ethical practices—along with Right Speech and Right Action—that Buddhists are expected to follow.

Dr. Rahula summarizes the requirements for Right Livelihood in this way:
“....one should abstain from making one’s living through a profession that brings harm to others...., and one should live by a profession that is honourable, blameless, and innocent of harm to others”. http://www.dhammaweb.net/books/Dr_Walpola_Rahula_What_the_Buddha_Taught.pdf

On first reading we are struck by the clarity of these words. Put simply, as Buddhists, we are to avoid occupations where we do harm.

But then we look at the complex nature of modern work. We let ourselves imagine the almost infinite connections we make through our daily exchanges as we make our living; connections that can have unpredictable consequences for individuals and circumstances a world away. We remember the numerous times the demands of our work life have forced us to submerge our ethics in a flood of rationalizations. When the reality is that we know we have to say yes to that demand we don’t agree with or overlook that unethical practice we know we shouldn’t condone. Because if we don’t we are fearful of losing our jobs and joining that increasing number of people who have permanently lost their grip on a secure future.   

Then the words that, at first, were so simple begin to seem simplistic.

That’s one of the challenges of bringing Buddhist practice into everyday life. The simplicity of the practice is compelling in a world where nothing seems simple. But after the honeymoon, when we have more or less mastered the art of sitting and following the breath, we attempt to take the practice into the real world. It’s at this point when we are forced past the apparent simplicity into a deeper felt awareness of the intention of the practice.

Of course, the ultimate intention of Buddhist practice is Enlightenment. However, on the path to Enlightenment and even after, the practice remains the same. It is to live each moment in full awareness. So that, to paraphrase the Buddha, when we are eating we know we are eating. When we are walking we know we are walking. When we are breathing we know that we are breathing. And, of course if we extrapolate the series we also practice so that when we are doing a task at work we know we are doing a task at work. We remain fully involved in that work task even if performing the task causes us to suffer or has us concerned that it may result in others’ suffering.

The Buddha was familiar with the ethical dilemmas that were part and parcel of living in the real world. As Stephen Batchelor reminds us in Living With the Devil, the Buddha negotiated the security of his Sangha within a brutal political system. And his moment by moment decisions about how to engage that system were made with compassion for the suffering of the Sangha in mind. But those decisions were also tempered by his understanding of realpolitik.

So as we move more fully into practice, just like the Buddha, we move away from thinking that Buddhism has a recipe for how to live an ethical life—at work as well as in the other parts of our lives. We are instead confronted with the reality that Buddhist practice simply sharpens our awareness. We see that we cannot avoid being a party to suffering in a culture driven by greed, ill will and ignorance. But then our compassion opens into an awareness that we too suffer. And taking wisdom along as our guide we step into the market place committed to end all suffering –remembering always to add "as best we can".

We will explore “As best we can” in the next posts and perhaps meet some people who are models of real world compassionate wisdom.
With Gratitude
Frank

0 comments: